SIMPLE SOURDOUGH STARTER DISCARD COFFEE CAKE RECIPE - NINNESCAH HOMESTEAD (2024)

This sourdough starter discard coffee cake is a delicious way to quickly and efficiently use up sourdough starter discard! Just be warned, this sourdough coffee cake can be best described as a cross between a funnel cake and powdered sugar donut! A unique twist on a traditional coffee cake!

​This sourdough coffee cake recipe might be my favorite sourdough discard recipe! It's the perfect sourdough discard coffee cake for a lazy Sunday morning, special occasion or even to enjoy as a leftover the next morning! Grab a cup of coffee, and let's make this easy coffee cake!

To make this recipe easier for you, I've broken it down into bite-sized pieces and included a helpful jump-to table of contents (below) and a jump-to recipe button (located at the top of this post).

WHAT IS SOURDOUGH STARTER DISCARD?

The obsession of baking crusty and fluffy home made sourdough bread has one clear drawback: discarding a portion of the unfed starter. When I say "sourdough starter discard," I am talking about a step in the feeding process where I remove a portion of the hungry sourdough starter and replace it with flour and water to "feed" the bacteria cultures and create fermentation.

For my basic sourdough recipes, I have a feeding routine that is very simple and easy to follow. My starter, like any hungry little house pet, needs food, water and attention to survive.

If you do not have a sourdough starter, read How to Make a Sourdough Starter and grow your own!

how to feed a sourdough starter

To feed my starter,I discard about half and add back in 1 scant cup all purpose flour and ½ cup of filtered water.I have a rubber band around the container to mark the starting height of the mixture. As it begins to bubble and grow from the fermentation process, the starter will grow past the rubber band and creep up the jar. If my starter is VERY active, for example on a day when I am baking multiple loaves and feeding it often, it will sometimes ferment itself right out of the jar!

If you are into a deeper dive of the chemical reaction, check out the caption on this time lapse video of my ultra-active starter overflowing!

HOW TO USE A SOURDOUGH STARTER DISCARD

A sourdough starter requires daily feeding if kept at room temperature, but on days when I am not baking, it can rest in the refrigerator for up to a week between feedings.

Not to worry! This can be a very simple process and the feelings of wastefulness can be cured with a few simple recipes!

When I am not in the mood or don't have time to bake with my discard, there are several ways I can make it disappear. I can either feed it to our chickens or pig, put it in a jar and refrigerate it for later, compost it or simply throw it away. This is truly 'discarding.'

To be honest, one of my favorite ways to make a discard disappear in the most delicious way possible is by baking with it!SOURDOUGH CRACKERS,SOURDOUGH CREPES,SOURDOUGH BANANA BREAD... there are so many tasty possibilities! I have even used a few tablespoons to thicken chicken and noodle soup or beef stew. If you are looking for an easy recipe, you've found it!

I also share my very favorite basic sourdough loaf recipe along with easy to follow tips in my post,HOW TO BAKE A PERFECT LOAF OF SOURDOUGH BREAD.

INGREDIENTS FOR EASY SOURDOUGH COFFEE CAKE

wet ingredients

200 GRAMS SOURDOUGH STARTER DISCARD ||The fed/hungry status of the discard really won't make a difference in this recipe! I store the leftover sourdough starter in a refrigerated mason jar. I'll use it in recipes for up to three weeks.

4 TABLESPOONS BUTTER, DIVIDED ||I use a fork to mix half of the butter in the coffee cake batter and use the other half to grease the cast iron skillet. Result? A crispy and crunchy crust!

dry ingredients

1 TABLESPOON BAKING POWDER | This turns the starter into a fluffy and light cake-like batter. Air bubbles form as the baking powder mixes with the flour in the starter and the batter puffs up within seconds.

2 TABLESPOONS SUGAR ||I like this coffee cake to be sweet. This amount of sugar does the trick! Feel free too scale up or down depending on preference. If you are not planning on serving this with maple syrup, I would add a few extra tablespoons of sugar.

1 TABLESPOON OATS ||I love dusting coffee cakes with a sprinkle of oats and brown sugar. It adds a layer of streusel-like texture to the coffee cake. Quick oats or steel cut oats are both fine!

1 HEAPING TABLESPOON BROWN SUGAR ||I prefer using light brown. It has less of a strong molasses flavor.

1 HEAPING teaspoon CINNAMON, DIVIDED ||Half of the cinnamon will be mixed into the batter. I add the remaining half to the faux-streusel topping. A little bit of warm cinnamon in each delicious bite!

¼ TEASPOON SEA SALT|| Sweet always needs a little salt to balance it out. In my kitchen, I use sea salt or Himalayan salt. These varieties contain beneficial trace minerals and nutrients that plain table salt is lacking.

1 TABLESPOON POWDERED SUGAR ||Just for fun, a dusting of powdered sugar makes this coffee cake feel extra special.

OPTIONAL || A teaspoon of vanilla extract in the batter. I also have made this recipe with fresh blueberries on top of the batter and it was delicious!

SERVING SUGGESTION ||Maple syrup for serving! Think of this as a crispy funnel-cake mixed with a pancake.

HOW TO MAKE SOURDOUGH STARTER DISCARD COFFEE CAKE

1. If the sourdough starter has been stored in the refrigerator, let it sit at room temperature for thirty minutes. Preheat the oven to 400 degrees Fahrenheit.
2. Preheat a cast iron skillet. Setting the oven to medium heat and letting the skillet slowly creep up to temperature allows it to cook evenly and be nonstick.
3. Add the starter, baking powder, 2 tablespoons of butter, white sugar, half of the cinnamon and sea salt in a medium mixing bowl. Whisk it together. This will be a thick batter!
4. Add two tablespoons of butter to the skillet and swirl it around the bottom and sides of the pan. It will begin to turn bubbly and brown, just like the browned butter I use in mySNICKERDOODLES. Browned butter has definitely become a lasting obsession in my kitchen!
5. Pour the batter into the skillet and gently spread it out over the melted butter. Sprinkle the top with the oats, brown sugar and remaining cinnamon for a simple crumb topping. Watch as the coffee cake begins to lightly fry along the edges of the pan. After about two minutes, the edge of the cake will be slightly crisped and cooked. Place the skillet in the oven to finish cooking for about ten minutes.
6. After the coffee cake has cooled a bit, my boys like to dust their slice with powdered sugar. This is the easy way to get kids excited about a delicious coffee cake!

You won't need a stand mixer or even a hand mixer for this original recipe! The only thing you'll need is a medium or large bowl to stir the sourdough mixture in and a cast iron skillet for baking. I am using a small skillet, and would recommend an 8 or 10-inch. The batter will resemble a thick pancake batter and can be stirred with a wooden spoon or spatula.

If you make this recipe, please leave a comment below! This provides helpful feedback to both me and other readers. For more delicious recipes from scratch and homesteading tips, follow me on instagram @NinnescahHomestead

Recipe

Ready for more recipes from scratch? Check out a few of my recent favorites!